a Trig Sum
motivated by a discussion on a math forum

Here's the problem:
        Does Σ cos(n)/n converge ... where the sum is from n = 1 to n = ∞?
>Lookin' at Figure 1, I'd say yes.
Can you prove it?

>Me? You kidding?
Let's try.
There's a test for convergence due to Dirichlet that says:

If the sequence an is decreasing and has a limit of 0
and the sum |Σbn| is bounded
then Σanbn converges.

>I pick an = 1/n because it decreases to 0. Right?
Yes, and I'll pick bn = cos(n).

>Then you gotta prove that Σ cos(n) is bounded.


Figure 1
Recall that ein = cos(n) + i sin(n).
Then Σ ein = Σ cos(n) + i Σ sin(n).
But Σ ein is a geometric series with a common ratio of ei so its sum (from n = 1 to n = N) is:   ei(1 - eiN) / (1 - ei)

>Huh?
Remember? a + ar + ar2 + ... + arN-1 = a (1 - rN)/(1 - r). In our case, a = r = ei.
Okay, so what's an upper bound on |Σcos(n)| ?

>I give up.
|Σcos(n)| < |Σ cos(n) + i Σ sin(n)| = |Σein| = |Σ ei(1 - eiN) / (1 - ei)| < |ei||1 - eiN| / |1 - ei| < 2/|1 - ei| = 1/SQRT[1 - cos(1)]
since 1 - ei = 1 - cos(1) - i sin(1) has a magnitude of SQRT[(1 - cos(1))2 + sin2(1)] =SQRT[ 2 - 2 cos(1)].

>Okay, so Σ cos(n)/n converges ... but to what?
I have no idea.


Mark S. provided this neat result:

Note that (Taylor series, eh?):
Σxn/n = -log(1 - x).

Setting x = ei we get:
Σxn/n = Σein/n = -log(1 - ei).

Then Σcos(n)/n = -RealPart{ Σein/n } = -RealPart{ log(1 - ei) }

But the log of a complex number R e is just log(R) + iθ so the RealPart is just log(R).

Note that: 1 - ei = 1 - cos(1) - i sin(1) = R e with R = SQRT[ (1 - cos(1) )2 + sin 2(1) ] = SQRT[ 2 - 2 cos(1) ].

So (finally): Σ cos(n)/n = - log(R) = - log[ SQRT[ 2 - 2 cos(1) ]] = 0.04202.

>Just like Figure 1, eh?
It looks that way, don't it.

See Math Stuff